One of the big goals of the US’s trade war, to hear Donald Trump tell it, is to bring back manufacturing jobs. If tariffs on cars from abroad have the desired effect of opening more factories in the US, it might not be a big win for unions like the United Auto Workers. Detroit bureau chief David Welch explains. Plus: What happens when Canadians stop visiting a town in Washington that’s dependent on them, and what it’s like running a freight business now. If this email was forwarded to you, click here to sign up. To hear some autoworkers tell it, President Donald Trump’s trade war is much-needed medicine to eradicate unfair deals, wipe away trade deficits and bring back towns in the heartland that long ago lost their steel mills, auto plants and machine shops. It’s a return to the days when most cars and appliances were made with pride by American hands. The pain and risk, they say, will be borne by the same people who’ve been profiting from America’s industrial decline for decades—that is, the C-suite leaders who chased labor savings over the border and around the globe in the name of earnings per share and the Wall Street fund managers who pressured them. The workers who don’t trust management or Wall Street may be experiencing some schadenfreude, but there’s also a belief that they’re burning the village to save the town. And what if their town gets burned? Vehicles on the trim assembly line at the General Motors assembly plant in Fort Wayne, Indiana. Photographer: Emily Elconin/Bloomberg To be clear, not all autoworkers are convinced Trump’s promise to use tariffs will bring back US manufacturing. Some union workers interviewed by Bloomberg suspect that tariffs will bring only inflation and not jobs. Trump’s supporters think tariffs are the only thing that will bring work back, and, since they’re already all-in on his social agenda, he has their full support. In November’s election, Trump won the majority of White men without a college degree, that is to say, working-class men. Democrat Kamala Harris kept a majority of union voters. One real risk to union autoworkers comes from the very same developments that Trump hails as a victory. In the past couple of months, Hyundai Motor Corp., Honda Motor Co. and Mercedes-Benz have all announced that they will bring more production to the US to avoid tariffs. That’s a win for Trump and workers who want auto jobs. But for union workers at General Motors Co., Ford Motor Co. and Stellantis NV, maybe not. Those investments will be made in nonunion plants in right-to-work states, mostly in the South. These workers won’t be new United Auto Workers members unless the union can organize these factories, which they have historically been bad at doing. For an example of what might happen, just look at South Korea’s Hyundai. The company opened its first US plant in 2005 in Alabama when it had less than 5% of the US market. Hyundai now has three American plants, and its US market share has more than doubled. Producing here lowers shipping costs and avoids tariffs. Companies that invest billions in manufacturing also tend to make products more tailored to local taste. If they do it right, they steal buyers. The workers in Hyundai’s factories don’t have union representation. Now look at GM. The automaker said last week that it faces up to $5 billion in tariff exposure. Management will try to mitigate the damage by running existing assembly lines faster and overall by getting leaner. But no matter how you dice it, a less profitable employer isn’t a good thing. UAW workers got $14,500 profit checks from GM and Ford workers got more than $10,000 last year. If tariffs broadly slow down the economy, as they did in the first quarter, that would pressure vehicle sales and profits even more. Union workers only win if Detroit’s automakers bring back some work from Mexico. They may have to over time, but more likely in parts and not higher-paying assembly jobs thanks to Trump pulling back on some tariffs. That will bring in some union jobs. What’s more clear is that Trump’s tariffs will at least cause interim pain for consumers and workers, and long term will likely create more jobs in the nonunion South. Subscribe to Hyperdrive, your daily guide to the future of cars, from reporters around the world. |