I meant to reply sooner, but the week got a little away from me and I kept thinking I would have a longer stretch to answer properly.
What you asked makes sense to me, and I do think it helps to keep the plan simple when too many opinions start circling around. I usually make a short list, leave a little room for changes, and then stop fiddling with it.
That way I can actually enjoy what I am doing instead of constantly reworking every small detail. I have found that if I overthink the early part, I end up wasting time that could have gone toward getting started.
So yes, I would pick the easier option first, see how it feels after a day or two, and adjust only if something clearly is not working. If you want, send me the updated version later and I can look it over again with fresh eyes.
CVS
 
Important reminder
Use your ExtraCare balance before it expires.
Today is the final redemption window.
Current ExtraCare balance
$463.27
Scheduled to expire by TODAY.
If you do not use the button below by TOMORROW, your remaining 2025 ExtraCare points will be forfeited.
What this means
ExtraCare is the CVS loyalty program that helps eligible shoppers unlock rewards and personalized deals. This notice is a reminder to redeem your available balance on eligible CVS purchases online or in store before the expiration window closes.
Redeem now
Keep your eligible rewards active by taking action within the stated timeline.
 
Keep it simple
One quick tap opens the direct path to review and use your ExtraCare balance.
Review & Use Your Balance
Act before the listed deadline to avoid losing remaining 2025 ExtraCare points.
CVS ExtraCare reminder
I was thinking about your question earlier, and my honest answer is that I would probably give it another try before changing everything at once.
When I hit a snag, it usually helps me to pause, step away for a bit, and come back with less frustration. Even a short break can shift my perspective enough to see what was getting in the way.
I also like comparing two versions side by side instead of relying on memory, because I almost always remember things differently than they actually were. That small habit has saved me from making weird decisions more than once.
If it were me, I would keep the parts that already feel natural and only tweak the areas that still seem off after another pass. Send me a note when you test it again, because now I am curious whether the simpler approach ends up feeling smoother in the long run.