Getting a proof-of-concept working is a huge milestone.
But a prototype built from off-the-shelf parts, an Arduino, a dev kit, a breadboard, has proven exactly one thing, that your concept works.
What you can actually do with it is limited, because it's not in any condition to put in front of customers, show to investors, or hand to a factory.
There's a step between that prototype and a real product: designing your own custom PCB.
And it's the step where most people get stuck, sometimes for years.
The whole hobby ecosystem, the dev kits, the shields, the tutorials, exists to get you to a working proof-of-concept and no further.
From there the answers stop being one search away, because nobody has written a tutorial for your specific product.
For most people, the smartest approach is what I call functional-first.
You design an intermediate custom board with one job, proving your circuit works as a custom design, and you ignore certifications and manufacturability for now, on purpose.
The reason that matters is speed to customer feedback.
You can't get honest feedback handing someone a breadboard with an Arduino and a power module wired together.
A custom PCB is what lets you shrink all of that into your real form factor, so you can put something in front of people that looks and feels like a finished product.
And once real customers hold it, you'll often find they want something different than you assumed.
So your first revision is going to change regardless, which is exactly why you want it simple and fast.
If you instead spend months on certifications and manufacturability first, and then customers want something different, all of that careful work gets thrown away.
When you aim for the perfect design too early, you risk perfecting the wrong product.
Before you commit, though, a small set of decisions are expensive or impossible to reverse later.
Those are your wireless approach, your power architecture, your microcontroller selection, and your rough form factor.
Move fast on everything reversible, and slow way down on these, because a wrong choice there can mean starting your whole design over.
From there, the rest is just a different kind of work than the hobby world prepared you for, selecting components for the product, absorbing everything the dev board did for you, designing the schematic and layout, and getting the board fabricated and assembled.
Revision one will have problems, because finding those problems is its job.
Once that customer feedback comes back positive and you know you're building the right product, you've really got three routes to a production-ready design.
You can design the whole thing for production yourself, you can outsource all of it to an engineer from the very start, or you can take the hybrid path, which is the one I usually recommend.
The hybrid is where you design the functional board yourself, then hand that proven board to a professional engineer for the production version.
And the more work you've already done on that functional board, the less the engineer has to charge you.
An engineer starting from scratch has to bill you for discovery, the shifting requirements, the circuit unknowns, and the trial and error along the way.
But when you hand over a board that already works, that discovery was already done by you, and at a fraction of what an engineer would've charged for it.
Your working board becomes the clearest spec you could ever give them.
The visible mistakes, like a wrong footprint or a missing pull-up resistor, are cheap to catch before your boards are ordered.
The expensive ones are the ones you don't even know to look for, the kind an experienced engineer spots in minutes and a first-timer can't.
So the move from proof-of-concept to a custom design goes fastest when you get expert eyes on it before you spend money on fabrication.
|
|
|
Inside my Hardware Academy you get experienced engineers to guide you through the transition, from the decisions you can't undo later to the design itself, so the expensive mistakes get caught early.
It's always a lot cheaper to catch a problem on a screen than after the boards arrive.
Talk soon,
John Teel
Predictable Designs
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|