One of my tutorials taught a member a mistake, and it took an engineer in my Hardware Academy to catch it.
The member had spent weeks on a compact custom keyboard device. He posted his files the day he joined, figuring it was ready for prototypes.
One of our engineers reviewed it the next day and complimented the clean, well organized schematic.
Then he got to the antenna, which didn't have enough clearance. Ground copper sat too close on both sides, which kills wireless range.
Next was a protection diode on the USB power input. The part was made for high-speed data lines and wasn't rated for surges on a 5V power rail.
So the board would power on and work fine, right up until the day it needed protection.
That mistake was actually mine. He'd copied that part of the schematic from one of my older tutorials, one I'd since corrected, but his board still carried the old version.
A review doesn't care where a mistake came from, even when it came from me.
He'd also been calling his regulator an LDO, and we pointed out it was really a switching regulator, which is exactly why it hit the efficiency numbers that drew him to it.
So we gave that part of the design a thorough review, and explained why a switcher was the right choice for driving that many LEDs, thanks to the high efficiency.
A switching regulator is also a lot more critical on layout than an LDO. Get the layout wrong and it can struggle to work, or turn into an EMI source for the whole board.
In round two he picked a proper protection diode, a great choice this time. Then the engineer caught it sitting too far from the connector with too few ground vias, which weakens the protection.
So over about two weeks the member posted revisions and got each one checked. Then his board went off to fabrication with every fix in.
While the order was in, a second engineer went through the layout like it's done at big companies, where nothing ships until a room of engineers picks it apart.
He flagged copper pour islands that can cause EMI trouble and a USB return path left to chance. He even noted the assembly house would want fiducials, the alignment marks pick-and-place machines use.
All of it went into his next revision. And every catch was essentially free, because it happened on a screen.
The expensive mistakes are the ones you don't know to look for. Some hide in places you trust, and an experienced engineer spots them in minutes.
Inside the Hardware Academy, getting experienced eyes on your design like this is part of your membership.
Talk soon,
John Teel
Predictable Designs
|
|
|
