St. Patrick’s Day is peak Guinness season, but American tariff proposals threaten to put a damper on the fun. Dublin bureau reporter Olivia Fletcher and New York podcast producer Stacey Vanek Smith—who both know their way around an Irish pub—bring us an update on the outlook for celebrations in honor of the Emerald Isle’s patron saint. Plus: Snap’s CEO on why its Spectacles are the superior tech glasses, and the long, sometimes dark, history of “Buy American.” If this email was forwarded to you, click here to sign up. Happy St. Patrick’s Day! In Ireland and around the world, it’s customary to enjoy the holiday with friends, family and—often—a tumbler of Irish whiskey or a pint of stout raised to cries of “sláinte,” or “good health” in Irish. For Americans, those cheers could become yelps of pain if US President Donald Trump makes good on his threat to impose a 200% tax on alcoholic drinks from the European Union. That could spell disaster for Diageo (the maker of Guinness, Baileys, Tanqueray and dozens of other brands), Pernod Ricard (Jameson whiskey, G.H. Mumm Champagne, Martell cognac), LVMH (Moët & Chandon, Veuve Clicquot, Hennessey cognac) and countless other companies. This is what a trade war looks like. Trump has said his tariff proposal will go into effect in April unless the EU backs off its threat of a 50% import tax on US bourbon (among other things). That itself came in response to a 25% levy the Trump administration has imposed on aluminum and steel imports from the bloc. “Everyone is trying to understand the worst-case scenario, but planning is extraordinarily difficult,” says Marten Lodewijks, president of IWSR, a beverage industry consultant. Irish whiskey sales in the US have flagged a bit in recent years, but Guinness has been on the rise—and Trump’s proposal would likely stop that cold. Lodewijks says a 25% tax on Scotch whisky during the first Trump administration in 2019 tanked sales by almost 20%. A 200% levy? “Catastrophic,” he says. “It pretty much shuts the market down.” Whiskey at the Pernod Ricard SA bottling plant in Dublin. Photographer: Aidan Crawley/Bloomberg The Irish whiskey lobby is urging both sides to sober up and remove alcohol from the trade spat, and European politicians are livid. France’s trade minister, Laurent Saint-Martin, has said the EU will protect its industries and won’t give in to Washington’s threats. Ireland’s prime minister, Micheal Martin, told reporters after meeting Trump at the White House last week that the bloc will craft an appropriate response. “It is a serious issue,” he said. “Europe has to be strategic in this.” At Molly’s Pub and Restaurant Shebeen in New York’s Gramercy Park neighborhood, shamrocks and Irish flags cover the walls, and waiters will serve up countless plates of corned beef and cabbage and Irish stew for the St. Patrick’s Day festivities. But the star of the show is Guinness: Owner Peter O’Connell expects to go through about 40 kegs today. “It’s as good as any pint you’ll have in Ireland,” O’Connell insists. Even a 200% tariff wouldn’t make him replace Jameson or Guinness with cheaper (and American-made) alternatives. “Oh, God, no. We’re Irish!” he says. The recent surge in inflation has already forced him to increase the price of a pint of stout to $10, O’Connell says, and the new tariffs might push that to $12, but not more. “We’re a middle-of-the-road place,” he says. “How much more can a customer take?” At least two customers—Katie and Larry Brydon—say there’s little that could steer them away from the classic Irish stout, particularly on St. Patrick’s Day. “Guinness is good for you,” Larry says, quaffing a pint at Molly’s. “It’s got antioxidants,” Katie chimes in, with a nod to her own glass. “You feel good when you drink it.” |