A Better Way to Handle Tough Leadership Decisions. As a leader, the decisions you make in high-stakes moments carry weight far beyond legal or operational impact—they shape trust, culture, and your credibility. When every option feels risky, here’s how to lead with clarity and care. Map trade-offs instead of reacting on instinct. Big decisions—think restructuring, layoffs, and policy shifts—carry legal, reputational, and cultural risks. Don’t assess those risks in isolation. Ask: What values are in tension?

Read online 

Manage email preferences

Harvard Business Review | The Management Tip of the Day
 

Today’s Tip

A Better Way to Handle Tough Leadership Decisions

As a leader, the decisions you make in high-stakes moments carry weight far beyond legal or operational impact—they shape trust, culture, and your credibility. When every option feels risky, here’s how to lead with clarity and care. 

Map trade-offs instead of reacting on instinct. Big decisions—think restructuring, layoffs, and policy shifts—carry legal, reputational, and cultural risks. Don’t assess those risks in isolation. Ask: What values are in tension? What trade-offs are we willing to make—and why? Bring in diverse voices early. You’re not just minimizing fallout; you’re deciding which risks are worth taking. 

Pressure-test before you roll out. Even good decisions land badly if they catch people off guard. Before you communicate, test reactions. What’s likely to confuse or alarm people or contradict your values? Involve those closest to the impact to surface issues before they become broken trust. 

Use principles to guide messy decisions. Policies are important, but principles shape how people experience change. Anchor your choices in shared values like empathy, clarity, and respect. Be explicit about who made the call, why it happened, and how you’ll support those affected. 

Say what’s happening and why. Don’t let people fill in the blanks. Be specific. Acknowledge what’s hard. Share what’s still unknown. Lead the narrative—or risk losing it. 

 

Read more in the article

How to Make a Seemingly Impossible Leadership Decision

by Daisy Auger-Domínguez

Read more in the article

How to Make a Seemingly Impossible Leadership Decision

by Daisy Auger-Domínguez

 

ADVERTISEMENT

 

A laptop displaying the HBR subscriptions webpage.

Work smarter with HBR

Get the insights, frameworks, and research trusted by leaders worldwide to stay sharp in a changing world.

Choose your plan

 
Coaching Real Leaders with Muriel Wilkins

Podcast

How Do I Handle So Much Organizational Uncertainty?

A leader worries about how to adjust as the tide changes at her organization.

Listen now
 

Leadership Unblocked: Break Through the Beliefs That Limit Your Potential

Leadership Unblocked: Break Through the Beliefs That Limit Your Potential

by Muriel Maignan Wilkins

Learn more

Don’t forget you’re entitled to 20% off your first purchase*

 

*Use promo code HBRORGREG4.
View details here.

 

 

The HBR App:
Get the best in leadership thinking on-the-go.

Download on the App Store.
Get it on Google Play
 
X IconFacebook Icon Instagram Icon

You are receiving this because you registered at hbr.org to receive The Management Tip of the Day emails, or you provided us with your email address.