Watching: Don’t You Be His Neighbor
It’s a traumatic day in the neighborhood.
Watching
June 3, 2026

Dear Watchers,

Horror is killing it, so to speak, at the box office right now. The one-two punch of “Obsession” and “Backrooms” has been taking audiences down some twisted rabbit holes. On this Genre Movie Wednesday, we have recommendations to continue your own dark little journey at home.

Our horror expert Erik Piepenburg highlights a couple of films that take children’s programming and warp it in sinister ways. The results are very much not for kids. One is about a Mister Rogers-like host whose friendly sidekicks turn sinister. The other involves a familiar-looking mouse with button shorts terrorizing riders on the Staten Island Ferry.

Read below to see what Erik admires about both movies, then head here for three more of his picks.

Happy Watching.

‘Monkey’s Magic Merry Go Round’

A man in a yellow cardigan and red bow tie stands smiling near a wooden post, with a green door and colorful walls in the background, resembling a friendly neighborhood setting.
Michael Gilio in “Monkey’s Magic Merry Go Round.” Screambox

Where to watch: Stream “Monkey’s Magic Merry Go Round” on Screambox.

His name is Mr. Jensen (Michael Gilio), but his furry puppet pals call him Jimbo. Soft-spoken and 1950s dad handsome, James is the host of a low-budget children’s television show who welcomes his audience to join him on the patio of his little house with a little garden that’s all just a little too creepy. When James spies a package inside his friend Marty the mailbox, James says to the camera: “I am fond of things that come in plastic bags.”

James also, it seems, has a problem. As he tells the puppets, “I can’t seem to recall much of anything.” One exception is a deadly fire, which looks in flashbacks like a fun house in flames. “Remembering hurts,” he says soon after sawing into his leg with a knife, but doing so is “how you heal yourself.” He doesn’t notice the blood seeping through his bandage.

Past traumas have sharp claws that dig deep in this strange and surprisingly heartfelt debut film from the director Aidan Leary, a combination of “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood,” “Avenue Q” and George Romero at his most existential (and gruesome). Gilio is exceptional as a man whose bright eyes and rigid bow tie belie the lifetime of pain underneath. Kyle William Stephens’s music is a wicked delight, especially in James’s mournful final number.

‘Screamboat’

A sinister furry mouse creature, wearing a hat, and pants with large buttons, stands near benches on a ferry holding a long spear with a blood-soaked blade.
A scene from “Screamboat.” Sleight of Hand Productions

Where to watch: Stream “Screamboat” for free on Amazon Prime Video.

If you’ve taken the Staten Island Ferry after the clubs close late Saturday night, you know that the trip can be a singular kind of terrifying. That’s nothing compared to what the ferry riders endure in this silly but entertaining and ultra-gory horror comedy from the writer-director (and Staten Island native) Steven LaMorte.

Like “Mickey’s Mouse Trap” and other recent scary-Mickey films, “Screamboat” takes advantage of the copyright expiration of “Steamboat Willie,” the 1928 animated short from Walt Disney that introduced Mickey Mouse. (The same public domain Wild West has horror-fied Winnie the Pooh, Popeye and Betty Boop.) Here, LaMorte set (and filmed) his movie almost entirely on the Staten Island Ferry, which is terrorized one night by a ratty little creature who whistles as he stalks and slays his victims.

Buoyed by lowbrow effects, the film is a dumb-fun mash-up of horror genres that feels whole, thanks in part to character actors who take stupidity seriously. (An animated segment about the monster’s back story is a lovely surprise.)

EXTRA-CREDIT READING

A man with short, curly dark hair and a beard wears a white T-shirt, leaning forward with his arms resting on a chair. He has a Mercy tattoo on his forearm.

Even on His Own, Nick Is Still a Jonas Brother

With a starring role in “Power Ballad” and ambitions across mediums, the 33-year-old is carving a singular path.

By Ashley Spencer and OK McCausland

A woman with curly hair sits at the open sliding door of a silver van, wearing a black and neon green outfit, with a serious expression.

Critic’s Notebook

The Tribeca Festival at 25: Artists Reign

The standouts from this year’s lineup include films about a cultlike theater troupe and an experimental dance residency.

By Natalia Winkelman

Kane Parsons and Chiwetel Ejiofor stand facing each other in an unfurnished room with yellowish wallpaper. The ceiling has office lighting. Each man is holding pages in his right hand, and a stepladder is in the left foreground.

Now in Theaters: Hit Movies From YouTube Stars

“Backrooms,” a psychological horror flick opening this weekend, is part of a wave of breakout films from fledgling directors who honed their instincts on YouTube.

By Brooks Barnes

A black-and-white close-up of Ginger Minj in full glam is framed in a pink and blue silhouette.

my ten

Ginger Minj Knows You Can Never Go Wrong With Rhinestones

“I blame Dolly Parton for this in some way,” the “RuPaul’s Drag Race” star said, “but it’s just right, it’s fun and it’s eye-catching.”

By Elisabeth Vincentelli

Out of the Audience, Into the Orchestra: Aspiring Musician Saves the Show

After a musician fell ill during a live performance of the score from “La La Land,” the composer Justin Hurwitz asked for a sight reader. A 21-year-old student stepped up.

By Claire Moses

A photorealistic, A.I.-generated image of a dark-haired woman in a black suit sitting in a black director’s chair. She is looking over her right shoulder at the camera. Text on the chair reads, “GENERATED BY A.I.”

I Profile Celebrities for a Living. Nothing Prepared Me for Tilly Norwood.

The A.I. actress on her craft, the future of film and how she definitely does not intend to murder us.

By Taffy Brodesser-Akner

If you received this newsletter from someone else, subscribe here.

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for Watching from The New York Times.

To stop receiving Watching, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on:

facebookxinstagramwhatsapp

Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices

The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018