Hi JMacek,

I just got validation back from the API team. If you are explicitly removing all members or owners ids you need to explicitly set the field to be an array. Otherwise, our provider automatically removes NULL fields and the API will see this and ignore the field changes.

The group's API is extremely old and is slated to be replaced. So try this and let me know if you still have issues. I am going to update the documentation for this resource to make this explicit.

Thanks,
John

Hi Jmacek, Sorry it took a little for me to dig into this. I think something is going on with the API and I am contacting the API team. Are you removing all ownerIds or just 1? When you "remove" the IDs are you completely removing the owner attribute or setting it to an empty array? What version…

Hi Jmacek,

Sorry it took a little for me to dig into this.

I think something is going on with the API and I am contacting the API team.

• Are you removing all ownerIds or just 1?
• When you "remove" the IDs are you completely removing the owner attribute or setting it to an empty array?
• What version of the provider you are working with? I am using 1.56.1
• With 1.56.1 can successfully remove owner IDs by setting the ownersId attribute=[]. (I do not get the owners
  removed if I remove the attribute.
• The reason I think it might be a problem with the APis is if I completely remove the owners field in the PUT then the API will not remove any of the owners. If you set the owners attribute in the API to an empty array it will trigger the API to remove the fields.

Thanks,
John

jmakacek:

Steps to reproduce: Create a group and assign some owner_ids. Then, remove the owner_ids from the Group and re-run.

"terraform plan" correctly identifies that owner_ids will be removed.

Hi jmakacek,

Happy New Year. I will open a ticket on my team and have someone take a look at it. It might be a little bit as the team is still coming back from the Holiday break and wrapping up the Sprint, but I will chat with them and see if we can get it on the backlog for the next Sprint.

Thanks,
John Carnell
Director, Developer Engagement

Hello,

It seems that removing Group owner_ids through TF is not working when we try to remove all of the Owners.

Steps to reproduce: Create a group and assign some owner_ids. Then, remove the owner_ids from the Group and re-run.

"terraform plan" correctly identifies that owner_ids will be removed.

"terraform apply" displays "...Modifications complete...", but the owner(s) are not actually removed.

Thank you.